Summary

Feedback taken at the end of the course. See the feedback in the first month.

Overall rating Insistence on LLVM Course project experience Exams experience Confidence in developing a new analysis Topics liked Topics hated

Details


Sr. No. Overall rating Insistence on LLVM Course project experience Exams experience Confidence in developing a new analysis Topics liked Topics hated Comments to improve the course
1 6   8   10   10   6   PTA, SHA, DYN, PAR   DFA, POL  "Thanks Sir for the classes which you conducted on fridays for better understanding for the students who lagged behind. I think more time could be spent on starting classes so that the student may grasp the fundamentals of the subject as this subject is new for the students who have not studied modern compilers, compared to other subjects. Rupesh sir is the best "  
2 10   8   9   6   9   DFA, PTA, DYN, PAR, SLI   SHA  "1.) Assignments shall be more in number (maybe a total of 4). We could have an assignment for each of these topics: DFA, PTA, DYN, PAR and SLI. We can also mix some of these topics, if time is an issue. I think that unless we practice a particular system's topic on system, the chances of it being very clear is very less. SHA doesn't sound that interesting or highly useful as compared to others on which we didn't have any assignment. 2.) More time could have been spent on POL, by reducing some from SHA. 3.) Paper presentations by students might be a better idea to make them learn some interesting and specific topics (other than the ones discussed in the course)."  
3 8   9       7   PTA, SHA, POL      
4 8   8   10   6   10   DFA, PTA, DYN, POL   SLI  I think more depth into the areas covered is needed. Exams need to be little tougher.  
5 9   9   9   9   7   PTA, SHA, DYN, PAR   POL, SEC   
6 9   10   10   8   6   DFA, PTA, DYN, PAR, SLI, SEC   SHA, POL  "Slides should contain more texts, so that when we look at the examples/problems later (mostly during the sem exams!) we can relate to the discussions that happened in the class. Otherwise, the subject is awesome. I didnt realize it, until i myself started talking PA terms in other classes. Thanks for making it a wonderful experience. "  
7 8   10   10   8   9   SHA, DYN, SLI   POL  If at any point if we get stuck in the class. I has to get cleared in the next class. If not, students does not get a connection and confidence on the topic.  
8 9   10   9   9   9   PTA, PAR, SEC   SHA, SLI  "The course was really a nice experience. It was an excellent example of making the students learn a lot without putting too much pressure; it is evident from the ethics followed by students too that enforcing everything is not a solution always. Some things I would like to be improved are the verification of examples in slides; there were cases that the examples were not clear (and were not resolved later too). Similarly there can be an extra written assignment too. Overall, I liked the teacher as well as the TAs, and had a nice journey of Program Analysis; the type of questions in exams also encouraged thinking and boosted the confidence."  
9 8   8   8   9   7   DYN, PAR, SLI, SEC   PTA   
10 8   7   8   4   2   PTA   SEC  please ask compiler background as pre requisite for the course next time  
11 8   10   8   8   7   PTA, SHA, DYN   SLI, SEC   
12               in my last feedback i would like to add that please show some leniency while giving grades to students who had not taken compiler in odd semester as their elective as they had to work many times more harder compared to other students  
13 10   9   10   10   10   SHA   POL   
14 9   5   10   9   9   PTA, DYN, PAR, SEC   SLI  "I am agree with that Detailed discussion is necessary for the good outcomes but Some time due to detailed discussion with Paceians, I am not able to get any thing. I was trying to understand the Basic in the class but because of that discussion every thing was mess up in my mind. I haven't took compiler in last semester so It's not easy for me to take every thing discussed in class. But, In the end i can say i have a good understanding of course. and thanks for the extra slot on Friday which helps me a lot."  
15 6   5   5   8   3   DFA, PTA, SHA, DYN, PAR, POL, SLI, SEC      
16 9   7   8   8   8   PTA, PAR, POL   SLI  None  
17 4   4   6   4   4   DFA, PTA, SHA   PAR, POL, SEC  The final feedback for this course is that it is a course where you don't get to learn more . And it is very difficult to score a good grade.  

course home page